Chatbot Legal Risks: Liability & Mitigation

AI chatbots are powerful tools, but they come with serious legal risks. Here’s what you need to know:

Companies are legally responsible for their chatbots’ actions
Key risks include data privacy violations, misinformation, and discrimination
Recent cases show courts hold businesses accountable for chatbot errors
Proper safeguards and insurance can help mitigate risks

Quick overview of main legal concerns:

Risk Area	Key Issues
Data Privacy	GDPR/CCPA compliance, data breaches
Misinformation	Incorrect info leading to damages
Discrimination	AI bias in decisions/recommendations
Contracts	Unclear terms, unauthorized agreements
IP Violations	Copyright/trademark infringement

To protect your company:

Use clear disclaimers and terms of use
Implement strong data security measures
Regularly audit chatbots for accuracy and bias
Get proper insurance coverage
Stay updated on evolving AI regulations

The bottom line: Chatbots offer great benefits, but require careful legal management to avoid costly mistakes. Balance innovation with compliance to build trust and minimize liability.

2. Data Privacy and Security

AI chatbots handle tons of personal info. That’s why data privacy is crucial for companies using them. Let’s dive into how GDPR and CCPA impact chatbot data handling.

GDPR and CCPA are game-changers for user data handling:

Law	What It Demands
GDPR (EU)	– Clear consent – Transparency – Data protection – User control
CCPA (California)	– Data collection disclosure – Opt-out option – Data security – User data access and deletion

These laws are reshaping chatbot operations. Companies must:

Get user permission before data collection
Be crystal clear about data usage
Protect data from breaches
Give users control over their info

Breaking these rules? It’ll cost you. GDPR fines can hit €20 million or 4% of global revenue, whichever hurts more.

2.1 Data Breach Risks

Poorly configured chatbots can leak data, leading to:

Identity theft
Financial fraud
Reputation damage

To dodge these bullets, companies should:

Use top-notch encryption
Restrict data access
Collect only essential data
Regularly audit security

Here’s a real-world example:

"Erica, Bank of America’s AI chatbot, helps customers manage money while keeping data locked down. We use hardcore encryption and strict data policies to shield customer info", says a Bank of America spokesperson.

3. Intellectual Property Issues

AI chatbots are stirring up a legal hornet’s nest in the world of intellectual property (IP). Companies using these chatbots need to keep their eyes peeled for potential copyright and trademark landmines.

3.1 Copyright and Trademark Concerns

Here’s the deal: chatbots can accidentally step on IP toes, leading to some serious legal headaches.

Copyright issues: Imagine your chatbot spitting out content that sounds suspiciously like a bestselling novel. Yep, that’s a problem.

Trademark troubles: Your chatbot casually drops a trademarked name or slogan? That’s another can of worms.

This isn’t just hypothetical. Take a look at this real-world example:

Getty Images took Stability AI to court, claiming they used over 12 million Getty photos to train their AI without permission. They’re crying foul on both copyright and trademark grounds.

Now, here’s where it gets interesting. The U.S. Copyright Office has laid down the law: AI-generated content without significant human input? Not copyrightable. Period.

AI Content Type	Can You Copyright It?
Pure AI output	Nope
AI + human tweaks	Maybe
Human-guided AI	Probably

So, how do you dodge these IP bullets?

Scrutinize your chatbot’s training data
Keep an eye on what your chatbot’s saying
Set clear rules for using AI-generated content

4. Consumer Protection

Chatbots can trick users and hide their AI nature. This can land companies in big legal trouble. Let’s look at some real cases:

Air Canada‘s Chatbot Mess

In 2022, Air Canada’s chatbot gave wrong info about bereavement fares. It led to a court case:

Jake Moffatt was told he could get a bereavement discount after booking
Air Canada said no when he tried
A court made Air Canada pay Moffatt $812.02

Air Canada tried to say the chatbot was separate from them. The court didn’t agree.

"It should be obvious to Air Canada that it is responsible for all the information on its website." – Christopher Rivers, tribunal member

Chevrolet‘s $1 Car Problem

A customer got Chevrolet’s chatbot to agree to sell a 2024 Chevy Tahoe for $1. How? By telling it to agree with everything. The dealership had to take the chatbot down.

Dangerous AI Meal Plans

Pak ‘n’ Save‘s AI meal planner suggested recipes with chlorine gas and bleach. These could kill someone. They had to fix it fast.

FTC Warnings

The FTC is getting tough on chatbot misuse. Here’s what they say:

FTC Warning	Meaning
No false claims	Don’t lie about what your chatbot can do
Be clear it’s a bot	Tell users they’re not talking to a human
Don’t exploit relationships	Don’t use chatbot familiarity to get data

What Companies Must Do

1. Train chatbots well: Make sure they give correct info

2. Add clear disclaimers: Say chatbot info isn’t final without human approval

3. Check all chatbot marketing: Make sure claims are true

4. Follow the rules: Stick to FTC and other chatbot laws

5. Offer human help: Always let users talk to a real person

Companies are responsible for their chatbots. As Gabor Lukacs from Air Passenger Rights said:

"If you are handing over part of your business to AI, you are responsible for what it does."

Chatbots can be useful, but they need careful watching to protect users and keep companies out of trouble.

5. Contracts and Chatbots

Chatbots are shaking up contract handling, but it’s not all smooth sailing. Let’s dive in:

Can Chatbots Make Legal Contracts?

Short answer: Yes, but it’s complicated. Courts only enforce contracts when both parties agree. With chatbots, this gets tricky.

Take these examples:

Clickwrap agreements? Good to go. Users click "I agree" and we’re set.
Browsewrap agreements? Not so fast. A link to terms isn’t enough.

Remember Nguyen v. Barnes and Noble Inc.? The court said terms links on every page didn’t cut it.

Chatbot Contract Risks

1. Wrong Info

Chatbots can mess up facts. Big time. A US lawyer used ChatGPT for a court brief and cited fake cases. Yikes.

2. Missing the Fine Print

Legal details? Chatbots might skip right over them.

3. Did They Really Agree?

Proving a user agreed to terms via chatbot? It’s a headache.

Playing It Safe with Chatbot Contracts

Do	Don’t
Use chatbots for basic templates	Trust chatbots with big deals
Get a lawyer’s eyes on it	Let chatbots run wild
Make users clearly say "YES"	Bury terms in chat
Keep chat logs	Assume all bot contracts work

Legal Smarts for Chatbot Contracts

1. Crystal Clear: Your bot should explain terms like you’re five.

2. Get the Thumbs Up: Make users click or type to agree.

3. Human Touch: Important contracts? Human check, always.

4. Bot Boundaries: Set clear rules for what your bot can do.

5. Stay Fresh: Keep your bot up to date on laws and policies.

"No lawyer? Low-value contract? A chatbot might do the trick. But tread carefully." – Alena Makarevich, Corporate and Commercial Associate.

6. Bias and Discrimination

Chatbots can be biased. This can lead to big problems for companies. Let’s look at the risks and how to avoid them.

The Bias Problem

AI learns from data. If that data is biased, so is the chatbot. This can cause unfair treatment.

Stanford Law School found chatbots gave different salary suggestions based on names. "Tamika" got $79,375. "Todd" got $82,485. Same job, different names.

Legal Trouble

Biased chatbots can break laws. The EEOC is taking action.

In 2022, iTutorGroup paid $365,000 for using AI that rejected older job applicants.

How to Keep Your Chatbot Fair

Test with diverse data
Review regularly
Get expert audits
Train your team
Set clear rules
Listen to concerns

What Courts Say

Judges are taking AI bias seriously. In California, a lawsuit against WorkDay‘s AI hiring tools is moving forward.

"Drawing an artificial distinction between software decision-makers and human decision-makers would potentially gut anti-discrimination laws in the modern era." – Judge Rita F. Lin

Protect Your Company

Understand your AI
Get bias test results
Start small
Team up to vet AI
Use anti-bias contracts

Remember: Fair AI is good for business and keeps you out of legal hot water.

7. Real Chatbot Legal Cases

Chatbots are landing companies in hot water. Here are some eye-opening cases:

7.1 Key Legal Cases

Air Canada’s Chatbot Mishap

In 2022, Air Canada lost a court case over its chatbot’s error:

Jake Moffatt asked about bereavement fares after his grandmother’s death
The bot wrongly said he could get a post-flight discount
Air Canada’s website stated: no refunds after travel
Moffatt sued when denied the discount
Court ordered Air Canada to pay $812.02

This case shows:

Companies are liable for chatbot mistakes
Chatbots aren’t legally separate from the company
Wrong info can trigger lawsuits

"It should be obvious to Air Canada that it is responsible for all the information on its website." – Christopher C. Rivers, Civil Resolution Tribunal Member

The WestJet Chatbot Blunder

In 2018, WestJet’s chatbot made a major error:

It accidentally sent a suicide prevention hotline link to a passenger
This highlights how AI can "hallucinate" or provide completely incorrect information

Key takeaways:

Test chatbots thoroughly before launch
Maintain human oversight on AI systems
Establish clear policies for chatbot errors

"If you are handing over part of your business to AI, you are responsible for what it does." – Gabor Lukacs, Air Passenger Rights

Companies using chatbots need to tread carefully. The law is catching up to AI, and mistakes can hit the bottom line hard.

8. Reducing Legal Risks

Want to use chatbots without legal headaches? Here’s how:

8.1 Data Protection Steps

Lock down user data:

Encrypt data in transit (HTTPS, SSL/TLS)
Use AES-256 for stored data
Set up access controls
Run regular security checks

8.2 Clear Terms of Use

Be upfront with users:

Chatbot info might not be 100% accurate
Users should double-check important stuff
Chatbot promises might not stick if they clash with company rules

8.3 Following Regulations

Know the rules:

Regulation	What You Need to Do
GDPR	Get consent, be transparent, secure data, give users control
CCPA	Be transparent, offer opt-outs, secure data, explain data use

8.4 Checking Chatbot Performance

Keep an eye on your bot:

Test before launch
Review logs regularly
Let humans handle tricky stuff

8.5 Staff and User Training

Educate everyone:

Teach staff AI basics
Tell users they’re talking to a bot
Show how to reach real people

"If you are handing over part of your business to AI, you are responsible for what it does." – Gabor Lukacs, Air Passenger Rights

This quote from the Air Canada case says it all. You can’t blame the bot – it’s on you to manage it right.

9. Legal-Friendly Chatbot Design

Want to keep your chatbot out of legal trouble? Here’s how:

Tell Users It’s AI

Be clear: your users are chatting with a bot, not a human. It’s not just good manners – it’s often the law. The Utah AI Prompt Act, for example, says you MUST tell people when they’re talking to AI.

A simple "Hey there! I’m an AI assistant. What can I help with?" works great.

Know Your Bot’s Limits

Don’t let your chatbot play doctor or lawyer. Stick to what it’s good at:

Go for It	Hands Off
Customer service basics	Financial advice
Product info	Medical diagnoses
Booking appointments	Legal help

Humans to the Rescue

Some things need a human touch. Make sure real people can jump in when things get tricky.

"In pharma, we’re slowly adopting AI, but always with human oversight to ensure accuracy and compliance." – Jonathan Shea, VP of IT at MacroGenics

Test Like Crazy

Before you unleash your bot:

Hunt for biases
Fact-check everything
Try to break it

And don’t stop testing after launch. Keep checking to catch problems early.

Guard That Data

Chatbots handle personal info. Lock it down:

Encrypt everything
Follow laws like GDPR
Only ask for what you need

Spell It Out

Write clear terms of use. Tell users what your bot can and can’t do. And remind them: bots aren’t perfect. Double-check anything important.

Stay in the Loop

AI laws are changing fast. Keep your eyes peeled for new rules that might affect your chatbot.

10. Insurance for Chatbot Risks

Chatbots are great, but they come with risks. Here’s how insurance can protect you:

Cyber Liability Insurance

Your first line of defense. Covers:

Data breaches
Cyberattacks
Other digital disasters

In 2022, chatbots saved businesses $8 billion. But they also created new risks.

Errors & Omissions (E&O) Insurance

Got your back when your chatbot messes up. Covers:

Professional mistakes
Negligence claims

Intellectual Property (IP) Insurance

Using big datasets to train your chatbot? IP insurance protects against infringement claims.

Commercial General Liability (CGL)

Covers physical harm caused by your AI:

Bodily injury
Property damage

Directors and Officers (D&O) Liability

Protects your top brass from AI-related mismanagement claims.

Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI)

If your chatbot helps with hiring, EPLI covers discrimination claims.

Media Liability Insurance

Covers AI-generated content issues:

Defamation
Privacy invasion

The Big Picture

Insurance Type	What It Covers
Cyber Liability	Data breaches, hacks
E&O	Professional errors
IP	Infringement claims
CGL	Physical harm
D&O	Executive protection
EPLI	Discrimination claims
Media Liability	Content issues

What You Need to Do

1. Talk to an Expert

Find an insurance broker who understands AI. They’ll help build a custom plan.

2. Read the Fine Print

AI is new. Make sure your policy actually covers it.

3. Stay Flexible

AI laws are changing fast. Your insurance needs might too.

"At least 54% of businesses using generative AI don’t fully understand its risks. That’s a huge liability exposure." – EY Report, 2022

4. Consider a Package Deal

Many insurers offer AI-specific bundles. Often cheaper than separate policies.

5. Regular Check-Ups

As your chatbot evolves, so do your risks. Review your coverage often.

Good insurance is like a safety net. It won’t prevent problems, but it can save you when they happen.

11. Future of Chatbot Laws

The chatbot legal landscape is evolving rapidly. Here’s what’s on the horizon:

Stricter Regulations

Governments are getting serious about AI risks. The EU’s AI Act is leading the pack:

Categorizes AI apps by risk level
Imposes tough rules on high-risk chatbots

The US is catching up, with NIST releasing an AI Risk Management Framework in January 2023.

Bias and Fairness Focus

New York City’s Local Law 144 is a game-changer, requiring bias audits for AI hiring tools since July 5, 2023. Expect more laws targeting AI discrimination.

Transparency Rules

Chatbots will need to disclose their AI nature. California’s Bot Disclosure Law is just the beginning.

Law	Purpose
California Bot Disclosure Law	Requires bots to identify as non-human
EU AI Act (proposed)	Identifies high-risk AI apps
NYC Local Law 144	Requires bias audits for AI hiring tools

Content Liability

Who’s on the hook when a chatbot gives bad advice? New laws will clarify:

New York’s A9381 bill could make chatbot owners liable for accuracy
This might force companies to tighten their AI controls

Tougher Data Protection

GDPR was just the start. Future laws will likely:

Restrict chatbot data usage
Demand explanations for AI decisions

Industry-Specific Rules

Expect targeted regulations in healthcare, finance, and legal services.

What Companies Should Do

1. Keep up with new laws

2. Regularly audit AI systems

3. Be transparent about chatbot operations

4. Train staff on AI ethics and compliance

"Unless all companies—including those not directly involved in AI development—engage early with these challenges, they risk eroding trust in AI-enabled products and triggering unnecessarily restrictive regulation." – Harvard Business Review

The takeaway? Chatbot laws are coming. Smart companies will stay ahead of the curve.

12. Conclusion

Chatbots are a double-edged sword for businesses. They offer great potential, but come with legal risks. Here’s what you need to know:

1. Data Privacy

Chatbots handle sensitive user data. This makes companies prime targets for data breaches and privacy violations.

2. Misinformation

AI can mess up. The Air Canada case shows how costly these mistakes can be:

"I find Air Canada did not take reasonable care to ensure its chatbot was accurate." – Civil Resolution Tribunal, Canada

3. Discrimination

AI bias is real. It can lead to unfair treatment and legal trouble.

4. Liability

You’re on the hook for your chatbot’s actions. Even if your team didn’t know about the issue.

So, what can you do? Start here:

Write clear terms of use
Audit your AI regularly
Train your team on AI ethics
Keep up with AI laws

The legal world is changing fast. The EU’s AI Act is cracking down on high-risk AI. In the US, laws like NYC’s Local Law 144 are targeting AI bias.

New AI Rules	What They Cover
EU AI Act	High-risk AI
NYC Local Law 144	AI hiring bias
California Bot Disclosure Law	Bot ID

Seth P. Berman of Nutter McClennen & Fish puts it well:

"History suggests we’ll look back at 2024 as a Wild West era for AI in the business world. But that same history suggests that Wild West legal eras are usually followed by periods of regulation by litigation."

The bottom line? Balance AI innovation with legal smarts. It’s the key to avoiding costly mistakes and building trust.

Back to blog

Contents

Related video from YouTube